Do Young Workers Still Have Summer Jobs?


Quarterly Workforce Indicators Show Youth Summer Employment Has Fallen Over the Last Few Decades

Young workers were once a consistently growing source of summer labor, but sharp declines coinciding with economic downturns have pushed third quarter youth employment to its lowest level in at least 28 years and the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) expects this trend to continue.

Historically, workers ages 14-18 have been much more likely to be employed at the beginning of the third quarter (July 1) than other times of the year, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s Quarterly Workforce Indicators (QWI) (Figure 1).

This pattern is not true for the overall workforce. The increase in employment from the second quarter to the third for all age cohorts is significantly smaller and there is no consistent decrease in employment from the third quarter to the fourth.

Figure 1. Quarterly Employment of All Workers vs. Workers Ages 14-18: 1993-2021

Summer employment for young workers also provides a crucial source of labor for employers in need of part-time and seasonal positions.

But that may be changing as young workers’ employment in the summer months has trended downward over the last 20 years, failing to fully recover from the early 2000’s recession and Great Recession.

Although summer employment and overall employment levels for young workers have rebounded over the last decade, they are still lower than before the Great Recession.

When looking at the beginning of third-quarter employment of young workers since 1993, none of the top 15 quarters have occurred in the last decade.

Economy and Summer Employment

Summer employment peaks for young workers have changed over time.

Although the 14-18 age cohort consistently exhibits the largest increases between spring and summer employment (third quarter minus second quarter), the magnitude of these increases fluctuates with external economic shocks, such as the Great Recession and the COVID-19 pandemic.

Going into the Great Recession, the percentage increase from the second quarter to the third quarter dropped to its lowest level in the time series (Figure 2).

After the recession, the summer employment boom for those ages 14-18 recovered quickly (after an increase of only 8% in 2009) to 17% in 2010 and a consistent percentage increase in the low 20’s from 2012-2017.

Figure 2. Second-to-Third Quarter Increase of Workers Ages 14-18: 1993-2020

Drop in Young People Working Summer Jobs

Although summer employment and overall employment levels for young workers have rebounded over the last decade, they are still lower than before the Great Recession.

Compare that trend with other age groups over this time period and the divergence of older and younger workers’ employment levels since the third quarter of 2000 is stark.

Older workers, particularly workers ages 55-64 and 65-99, comprise an increasing share of the employed population (Figure 3).

Interestingly, employment levels for workers ages 14-18 dropped the most during the Great Recession. Summer employment for the youngest workers fell substantially in 2008 and 2009 and has not recovered as quickly as for older age groups.

Figure 3. Employment by Worker Age: 1993-2020

It’s too early to tell how the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted summer employment for young workers, but we can see workers ages 14-18 had the second largest percentage drop in the beginning of third-quarter employment between 2019 and 2020 (Table 1).

Additional quarterly data will allow for a more complete understanding of this dynamic.

Table 1. Percentage Decline in Third Quarter Employment by Worker Age between 2019 and 2020

Youth Summer Employment by State

How do these trends differ at the state level?

The top 10 states for share of employment for workers ages 14-18 over the last 20 years are South Dakota, Utah, Iowa, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Wyoming, Idaho, North Dakota, Minnesota, and Montana.

These states are diverse in terms of where they rank for population share under the age of 18 as of 2019 — South Dakota, Utah, Nebraska, and Idaho rank in the top 10, while Montana and Wisconsin are in the bottom half of states.

Summer youth employment in North Dakota weathered the Great Recession better than other states, perhaps due to employment opportunities during the Bakken oil boom (Figure 4).

But employment has not kept pace with other states’ growth since 2015. Contrast that with Idaho and Utah, where youth employment was significantly impacted by the Great Recession but has increased dramatically in the last decade.

Youth summer employment in Idaho, Utah, and Montana appear to have been impacted the least by the COVID-19 pandemic, as of the third quarter of 2021.

Figure 4. Employment of Workers Ages 14-18 in Ten States: 2001-2021

Youth Summer Earnings by State

What youth earn for working over the summer varies by state.

Average monthly earnings for young workers for the 10 most recent third quarters (2011-2020) show that the District of Columbia, California, Washington, Oregon, and Nevada offer the highest earnings for young workers (Figure 5).

Young workers employed in states in the Midwest and South had the lowest summer earnings over this time period.

Figure 5. Third Quarter Average Monthly Earnings of Workers Ages 14-18 by State: 2011-2020

These geographic patterns are not unique to young workers — states on the east and west coasts offered the highest earnings for older workers, too. Massachusetts, New York, and Connecticut are in the top five states for third quarter earnings for workers older than 19.

State and regional differences in youth summer employment and earnings can be driven by industry-level trends, as discussed below.

Youth Summer Employment by Industry

Employment as of July 1 in the Retail Trade and Accommodation and Food Services sectors dwarf other industries in its share of young worker employment (Figure 6).

FIgure 6. Employment of Workers Ages 14-18 by NAICS Sector: 1993-2020

But the story changes when we look at employment changes since the beginning of the time series in 1993 (Figure 7).

Employment in Education Services has grown the most since 1993, followed by Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation. Interestingly, Transportation and Warehousing has also surged in the last 5 years, perhaps due to the increasing demand for delivery drivers and warehouse workers.

Figure 7. Employment of Workers Ages 14-18 by NAICS Sector: 1993-2020

Youth Summer Earnings by Industry

How do summer earnings for workers ages 14-18 vary by industry?

Workers ages 14-18 in Mining, Quarrying and Oil/Gas Extraction earned the most in the third quarter, followed by Construction (Figure 8). Note the Mining industry accounted for less than 0.1% of third quarter youth employment over this period for this age group, while Construction accounted for almost 3%.

Figure 8. Third Quarter Average Monthly Earnings by NAICS Sector and Worker Age: 2016-2020

While summer earnings have steadily increased for young workers over time, these increases have been relatively evenly distributed between industries.

Article Courtesy of the US Census Bureau